Free: read the opening chapters of Robert's two newest books → Get the free samples

Relationships & Emotional Healing

How to Stop Being Defensive: Listen With Love, Not Armor

By Robert Anderson Love Wins · · 5 min read

Someone says, "Can we talk about something?" and before they've finished the sentence, your chest tightens. You're already building your case, remembering everything they got wrong, getting ready to explain why it isn't your fault. If you've been searching for how to stop being defensive, you're not broken and you're not alone. Defensiveness is a very human reflex. It's the heart trying to protect itself. The good news is that you can teach that heart a gentler way to feel safe.

Everything I write grows from one root: love, kindness, caring, value and respect for everybody involved. That means the person who is speaking to you, and it also means you. Defensiveness usually shows up when one of those feels threatened, most often our own sense of value.

Why We Get Defensive in the First Place

Defensiveness is rarely about the words in front of us. It's about what we hear underneath them. "You forgot to call" turns into "You don't care." "This report needs work" becomes "You're not good enough." The other person describes a moment, and we hear a verdict on our whole worth.

In From Pain to Purpose, Fear to Freedom, I wrote:

"Emotions determine whether we approach challenges with courage or retreat in fear, whether we communicate with empathy or react defensively."

That's the key. Defensiveness isn't a character flaw; it's an emotional state. And emotional states can be noticed, named and guided.

I've spent much of my life around animals, and they teach this lesson without a single word. In The Divine Harmony Planner's Handbook, I put it this way: "If you radiate fear, they flee or defend. If you radiate calm, loving presence, they respond with curiosity and trust." People aren't so different. When we feel afraid, we defend. When we feel safe, we get curious.

How to Stop Being Defensive: Six Kind Practices

1. Notice the alarm in your body

Defensiveness starts in the body before it reaches your mouth: a hot face, a tight jaw, crossed arms, words forming fast. Learn your own early signs. The moment you notice them, you've already won a little space. In my post on how to respond instead of react, I call this the sacred pause. One slow breath is often enough to let your thinking catch up with your feelings.

2. Name what you're feeling, gently

From Pain to Purpose offers a simple first step: "Acknowledge Your Emotions: Don’t suppress or ignore your feelings. Instead, take a moment to identify and label what you’re experiencing. Awareness is the first step toward control." Quietly say to yourself, "I'm feeling embarrassed," or "I'm scared they're disappointed in me." A named feeling is much easier to hold than an unnamed one.

3. Change the voice inside your head

Most defensiveness is fed by harsh self-talk. Someone points out a mistake, and the inner critic shouts, "See? You always mess up." No wonder we fight back. We're not only defending against them; we're defending against ourselves.

Try a kinder inner sentence instead: "I can make a mistake and still be a good person." Or, "This is feedback about a moment, not a verdict on me." If that inner critic is loud for you, my post on how to stop negative self-talk walks through how to retrain it. And if your defensiveness comes from needing to be flawless, How to Stop Being a Perfectionist may feel like it was written for you.

Want more gentle, practical tools like these? You can read the opening chapters of my two newest books for free on the free samples page. It's an easy place to start.

4. Listen to understand, not to reply

When we're defensive, we listen for the flaw in the other person's argument so we can answer it. Try listening for their feeling instead. What are they worried about? What do they need? You might say, "Let me make sure I understand. You felt left out when I made the plan without you?" That one question changes the whole temperature of a conversation.

5. Find the piece that's true

You don't have to agree with everything to agree with something. Look for the grain of truth and say it out loud: "You're right, I did cut you off." Owning one honest piece doesn't make you smaller. It makes you trustworthy, and it often helps the other person soften too.

6. Let go of winning

This is the heart of my book I’m Not Right, You’re Not Wrong: A Guide to Meaningful Connection. The title itself is the practice. Its description talks about helping readers "Cultivate self-awareness and a mindset of collaboration over competition" and "Navigate conflicts with grace and transform disagreements into opportunities for growth." When the goal stops being "prove I'm right" and becomes "understand each other," there's nothing left to defend.

What to Say When You Feel Defensive

Having a few phrases ready can help when your feelings run ahead of you:

  • "Give me a moment. I want to really hear this."
  • "I'm feeling a little defensive, and I don't want that to get in the way."
  • "Tell me more about what that was like for you."
  • "You're right about that part. Thank you for telling me."
  • "Can we come back to this in an hour? I want to answer with care, not in a rush."

None of these mean you have to accept unkind treatment. Listening with love and keeping healthy limits go together. If a conversation turns into a real disagreement, my guide on how to disagree without arguing can help you hold your ground with respect.

When You Slip

You'll still get defensive sometimes. Everyone does, especially when tired or hurting. When it happens, go back and repair: "Earlier I got defensive and didn't really listen. Can we try again?" That sentence takes courage, and it builds more trust than never slipping at all. Then speak kindly to yourself about it, the same way you'd speak to a friend who was learning something new.

Your Next Step

The next time someone brings you something hard, try just one thing: take a breath, then ask one question to understand before you explain anything. Notice what changes.

If you'd like to go deeper into calm, caring communication, explore I’m Not Right, You’re Not Wrong and watch the short book video. And for a free place to begin today, grab the opening chapters on the free samples page. You don't need armor to be safe. Love, kindness and respect, given to yourself and to others, are a far stronger protection.

Source: I’m Not Right, You’re Not Wrong: A Guide to Meaningful Connection

Keep reading

Watch

#defensiveness #listening without getting defensive #communication #relationships #self-talk #I'm Not Right You're Not Wrong

Robert Anderson Love Wins, author

About the author

Robert Anderson Love Wins

Author of 147 books on healing, faith and personal growth, speaker, and writer of the Empower You to Empower Others newsletter on LinkedIn.

Related posts

Free gift

Get free samples of Robert's two newest books

The opening chapters of From Pain to Purpose, Fear to Freedom and The Divine Harmony Planner's Handbook, as PDFs.

Free weekly reading

Empower You to Empower Others

Robert's LinkedIn newsletter: essays on faith, healing, relationships, and personal growth. Join the newsletter.

Subscribe on LinkedIn